Inside Sabertooth
Learn how Sabertooth uses 3ds Max to create 3D interactive projects, including HBO Go’s Game of Thrones interactive experience
  • 1/3
  RSS 2.0 ATOM  

Mac or PC?
Rate this thread
 
40406
 
Permlink of this thread  
avatar
  • Total Posts: 19
  • Joined: 17 January 2010 03:02 AM

I’m just starting to learn Maya 2010. I Have wanted to get a new computer but wanted to know what i should get. Mac, or PC? What do you guys think? Thanks, Jeff



Replies: 0
avatar
  • olygraph
  • Posted: 05 March 2010 01:37 AM

huumm I think maya for mac is not 64bit. This would be a big reason to me not to go there. Its kind of a big lost of hardware.  If you want any third party plugin like renderers, I also think they need to be available for the MAC, wich it seem to be more and more popular, but sometime it is not available.

Also, correct me if i’m wrong, but 32bit apps cannot get more than 4gb of ram by the OS. I’m running with this issue with zbrush and after effect (in none multiprocessing mode). So if you have more than 4gb RAM, you’ll just waste your money. execpt if you would like to run 2 instances of maya at the same time :P.

Otherwise MAC as a good OS and seem to be very stable. But Me i’m running on windows since a long time and I personnaly prefer it.



Oly

Replies: 2
/img/forum/dark/default_avatar.png

cool, thanks. I went to Boxx, I live here in Austin, and check them out. Do you like that work station? I am still looking into that as well. Thanks for the feed back

Author: tattoobaker

Replied: 05 March 2010 05:35 PM  
/userdata/avatar/6m1amcays_mask100.jpg

Yeah those machine are pretty strong and are made by professionals who knows Maya and most of the 3D applications. My machine is working so good, I can have all the applications I need opened at the same time. I have like 12GB of RAM and two Quad Core. And another reason why I buy it, its because of the xeon chipset, which enable me to upgrade my machine up to 24GB of ram in the future, because there 12SLOT of RAM and I use only 6. And Boxx told be that there is 95% of chance this board will be compatible with the next generation of processor (like 6 or 8 Core processors).

Meanwhile those machines are pretty expensive. Also, if you buy A Quadro graphic card, you wont be able to play games with your machine. It is good only for work applications. Most of the people at home don’t want to pay that huge price for the small advantages it give you. Also with BOXX, an amouth of your money will go in the support. They have an very excellent team for support and if never, for what ever reason your PC makes maya goes wrong, they’ll help you very fast. If you computer break in the first year, they’ll pay the shipping costs, and they will try to repair it as fast as they can.

If you just want to have a good strong computer for multitasking, like gaming or programming with directx, xna or whatever windows is good at, I suggest you to buy a good i7processor, with descent RAM and motherboard. and you will be as happy as with a BOXX if you dont use 3D applications extensively, and you will save a LOT of $$ and maybe use it to buy a little trip to elsewhere in the world which worth it :P. Just be aware that sometime some graphic card and board goes wrong or are completely incompatible with Maya or other software. Autodesk did some tests on that, they have a chart sticked right in the first post of this forum.

Author: olygraph

Replied: 06 March 2010 04:50 AM  
avatar
  • THNKR
  • Posted: 05 March 2010 02:45 AM

If you buy a Mac, you can run all three OSs that Maya runs on. That’s one of the reasons why I use Apple hardware. It does limit the number of available graphics cards, which may or may not be important to you.



Replies: 1
/userdata/avatar/6m1amcays_mask100.jpg

Yeah I was talking more about the Os than the machine. MAC has very very good hardwares, actually the same as my PC machine (BOXX). The only reason I bought a PC is for the Quadro. I know there is a special Quadro card for MAC and I didn’t know if it was supported for windows. Do you know if this card or any other MAC Graphic Card is good or supported for windows and Maya for Windows?

But yeah, in fact the advantage of having a MAC is the possibility to have multiple OS including MAC OSX. I’m just scare about the compatibility and the support for Windows on the graphic hardware.

Author: olygraph

Replied: 05 March 2010 03:03 AM  
avatar
  • THNKR
  • Posted: 05 March 2010 05:46 AM

You might want to be a bit cautious about getting a Quadro if you’re running Mac OS X. The Quadro FX 4800 that is qualified for Mac OS X has driver issues that affect performance under OS X. See http://arstechnica.com/apple/new...o-fx-4800-mac-edition.ars



Replies: 0