AREA forums upgrade
Read more about the planned upgrade of our forums
  • 1/3
You are here: Forum Home / Autodesk® Smoke® / Smoke 2013 / Feature request - video audio sync
IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT ABOUT AREA FORUMS
  RSS 2.0 ATOM  

Feature request - video audio sync
Rate this thread
 
73221
 
Permlink of this thread  
avatar
  • Mindseye
  • Posted: 15 November 2012 02:37 AM
  • Total Posts: 530
  • Joined: 26 December 2009 06:26 AM

Why is it that in smoke the audio and video are detached from one another when you place them in the timeline. They easily get out of sync. You have to group them and do other work arounds. In other apps, the application automatically keep them in-sync and you have to make an effort to un-sync them. This has always thrown me off in Smoke.

I know that you can group them, but why not use a more elegant way?
In FCP you had to click alt and the audio track to work with audio only. That was quick in and out. Didn’t have to go into a menu, and it was clip specific, whilst smoke is timeline specific.

Snap is an example of a sticky feature.



Jeffrey Levenstone
It isn’t done until it is finished.

Replies: 1
/img/forum/light/default_avatar.png

I totally agree.
Link Selection is something that should be available via shortcut, not in a menu.

André

Author: andrega

Replied: 15 November 2012 03:21 AM  
avatar

Hi

Just a few comments here.

If you imported your clip that had a synced video and audio source when edit the clips into the timeline, they should still be locked and in sync together.  I have been testing it here with a few synced clips and the sync stays corrected with the video and audio and long as the LINK SELECTION is on.

You should also see the underline underneath the segment name which tells you whether or not the clip is part of a group.

Or are you importing separate video and audio clips?

I will log a request for LINK SELECTION to be mapped to a shortcut or a button.

Regards
Grant



Replies: 3
/img/forum/light/default_avatar.png

Hello Grant,

The other thing is that if they are linked, to do a L cut you have to dig into menus to un-link do the L-cut then back into menu to Relink. In FCP you just held down the alt key and you could select the audio or video alone and on releasing the alt, the link was back to it’s normal state.  It functions as a sort toggle select mode.

Author: Mindseye

Replied: 15 November 2012 09:29 PM  
/userdata/avatar/0cixbi4fi_avatar.jpg

Hi Jeffrey,

I will pass that info onto the team.

Many thanks!

Regards
Grant

Author: Ultimate_Smoker*

Replied: 15 November 2012 09:44 PM  
/img/forum/light/default_avatar.png

Thanks Grant.

Author: Mindseye

Replied: 16 November 2012 12:50 AM  
avatar
  • robcoulin
  • Posted: 16 November 2012 12:38 AM

hi,

became a bit easier in the current version - with the “flipped return icon” on the tracks left of the timeline you can un/sync individual tracks with a click.
i guess the “sync groups” still exist, but obviously the sync icon is much simpler to administrate ...
L-cuts or such are still not ideal with smoke ....

robert



- robert (unified)

Replies: 0